HATRED

[Warby]

I am really dissapointed in everyone ... game-news-sites, valve, podcasters, youtuber folks, etc...

Everyone draws way too much attention to this game 

 

Just let it exist AND die in obscurity.

[SuperDuperYeah]

I am really dissapointed in everyone ... game-news-sites, valve, podcasters, youtuber folks, etc...

Everyone draws way too much attention to this game 

 

Just let it exist AND die in obscurity.

 

A-fucking-men. 

[Steppenwolf]

Let adults decide what they want to buy/play. This patronizing is bullshit. What i really don't like about this is the precedent it sets. First GTA V now this. It sends a wrong signal to easily offended morons that they just have to be loud enough to get games banned (if not by law then from stores which boils down to the same result). I bet it doesn't take long and some groups want to get more harmless games banned because of muh sexism or whatever.

[Sprony]

[dux]

It's a dumb game but removing it is dumber.

[FMPONE]

People shouldn't be forced to publish shit they don't want to, and this game is fucking trash. I'd have made the same decision 

[DrywallDreams]

This decision just cements Valve's status as the PC App Store (and Valve's generally crap moderation).  I respect Valve's decision to reject this game, but their policies are way too spotty right now.  

 

Steam, while trying to open up with Greenlight, still is a curated store, and partially thrives upon that.  The games they let through generally reflect Valve's views to the public.  Look at any 2 second Unity game that has been let through, you see many complaining that Valve let those through.

 

This is all they say about forbidden content on the required donation page: 

 

 

• Porn, inappropriate or offensive content, warez or leaked content 

 

Clearly "offensive content" needs to be expanded upon.

 

Surely desura will be excited about their hot exclusive though

[-HP-]

People shouldn't be forced to publish shit they don't want to, and this game is fucking trash. I'd have made the same decision 

 

I'm sorry dude, but that kind of judgmental and "moral high ground" mentality is exactly the same as religious fanatics, thinking their entitled to make decisions for everyone else because their "morals" are telling them what's right and what's wrong.

 

Let the human collective answer the question on whether or not they want this, not the individual in power. In theory, that's what Greenlight is, right?

 

PS. The game is trash tho, definitely agree with you there, i'm not defending the game, i'm talking about valves decision here, it could be a porn version of pac-man instead of hatred.

[jackophant]

This decision just cements Valve's status as the PC App Store (and Valve's generally crap moderation).  I "respect" Valve's decision to reject this game, but their policies are way too spotty right now I think they're wrong. (FTFY)

 

Steam, while trying to open up with Greenlight, still is a curated store, and partially thrives upon that.  The games they let through generally reflect Valve's views to the public.  Look at any 2 second Unity game that has been let through, you see many complaining that Valve let those through.

 

This is all they say about forbidden content on the required donation page: 

• Porn, inappropriate or offensive content, warez or leaked content 

 

Clearly "offensive content" needs to be expanded upon.

 

Surely desura will be excited about their hot exclusive though

 

It's a PR move, can you imagine the shitstorm if they allowed it to be sold? As far as I'm concerned this game comes under porn (as murder porn), inappropriate and offensive.

 

The game doesn't offend me, I just think it's a stupid fucking idea that will only end badly.

 

If anyone is actually looking forward to this game, regardless of shooting pixels and the lack of correlation between "anti-social behaviour" and violence in video games, they need to get their head checked.

[DrywallDreams]

 

People shouldn't be forced to publish shit they don't want to, and this game is fucking trash. I'd have made the same decision 

 

I'm sorry dude, but that kind of judgmental and "moral high ground" mentality is exactly the same as religious fanatics, thinking their entitled to make decisions for everyone else because their "morals" are telling them what's right and what's wrong.

 

Let the human collective answer the question on whether or not they want this, not the individual in power. In theory, that's what Greenlight is, right?

 

PS. The game is trash tho, definitely agree with you there, i'm not defending the game, i'm talking about valves decision here, it could be a porn version of pac-man instead of hatred.

 

While yeah, that kind of thinking is crazy, this isn't banning the game's existence.  Steam is still tied to Valve's reputation, thus Valve don't publish games that they don't want to represent them.  While Greenlight can set a sort of quality standard, Valve wouldn't let Greenlight speak for them.  It's easy to see the internet greenlighting a game called "hitler did nothing wrong" when greenlight is only based on up/downvotes.  Just look at some of the garbage reddit upvotes.  

[FMPONE]

 

People shouldn't be forced to publish shit they don't want to, and this game is fucking trash. I'd have made the same decision 

 

I'm sorry dude, but that kind of judgmental and "moral high ground" mentality is exactly the same as religious fanatics, thinking their entitled to make decisions for everyone else because their "morals" are telling them what's right and what's wrong.

 

Let the human collective answer the question on whether or not they want this, not the individual in power. In theory, that's what Greenlight is, right?

 

PS. The game is trash tho, definitely agree with you there, i'm not defending the game, i'm talking about valves decision here, it could be a porn version of pac-man instead of hatred.

 

 

You could say the same thing about you forcing Steam to publish the game. Why are you making them publish something they don't want to publish? It's their platform, why are you trying to make the decision for them? Nobody is saying the game is against the law, they're saying they don't want to publish it. Big difference.

[DrywallDreams]

 

This decision just cements Valve's status as the PC App Store (and Valve's generally crap moderation).  I "respect" Valve's decision to reject this game, but their policies are way too spotty right now I think they're wrong. (FTFY)

 

Steam, while trying to open up with Greenlight, still is a curated store, and partially thrives upon that.  The games they let through generally reflect Valve's views to the public.  Look at any 2 second Unity game that has been let through, you see many complaining that Valve let those through.

 

This is all they say about forbidden content on the required donation page: 

• Porn, inappropriate or offensive content, warez or leaked content 

 

Clearly "offensive content" needs to be expanded upon.

 

Surely desura will be excited about their hot exclusive though

 

It's a PR move, can you imagine the shitstorm if they allowed it to be sold? As far as I'm concerned this game comes under porn (as murder porn), inappropriate and offensive.

 

The game doesn't offend me, I just think it's a stupid fucking idea that will only end badly.

 

If anyone is actually looking forward to this game, regardless of shooting pixels and the lack of correlation between "anti-social behaviour" and violence in video games, they need to get their head checked.

 

I fully meant that I respect their decision.  Honestly, if I were in Valve's position, I wouldn't publish the game.  Valve, though, has been historically bad in terms of moderation/setting clear standards.  Look at a game like Sakura Spirit.  The game's store page states "This game includes nudity and explicit sexual dialog.", so how did the game get on Steam, so wouldn't that be against the "No porn" rule that is stated on the Greenlight donation page?  

[DrywallDreams]

And like that, it's back on Greenlight, Valve moderation at its finest. :/

[blackdog]

Also, I remember them/Gabe stating that Greenlight failed as a project and that was going to be abandoned…

Ps: nudity != porn

Edited December 17, 2014 by blackdog

[knj]

Well Game mailed  then, that this was a bad decision and they are back