Quote from TaylorThey are?.
I don't know how many games you play outside of RPGs and RTS titles (these admittedly still put a lot of focus on gameplay), but in other genres I'd say that gameplay and fun has very much been compromised by striving towards a 'cinematic' experience with the finest graphics and set-pieces. We're in an age where there's an abundance of games that look fantastic, and little more. Pretty much every current-gen console action game has fell into this category for me.
And just to clarify the applaud comment, I didn't mean that they should be applauded simply for doing something different. I meant they should be applauded for doing something different really well. This is one of the best examples I've seen of a game providing an experience that only a game can provide: being a fantastic toy.
Of course, it's this very open-ended toy-like nature that seems to turn a number of Mapcorians off.
I say: does a game need a story like a film to be good? Is a basic structure like Spore has not enough?