To be fair, it's not just a case of art. The whole game was essentially a clone, right down to the exact mechanics. And what unique art it did have was virtually directly ripped from Mario. In a world where Zynga is criticised for cloning games like Tiny Tower and countless others, why is it OK for an individual to do it? I'm not even an indie game developer and it seems very unsavoury to me.
The fact that he put the game through Apple's approval process, monetised it, and probably made quite a nice sum out of it made his intentions quite clear IMO. Sure developers often create little experimental games that are hugely derivative, but they don't put them on the equivalent of a high street game store shelf. I've designed UIs that are essentially complete copies of existing ones just to learn how to build such a thing, but I wouldn't then go and pitch/sell it as a product. If nothing else, I'd feel like a dick.
It's a matter of opinion, but I don't see him taking the game down as evidence of him being some totally innocent guy who's been inappropriately bashed. I see him more like someone who took a chance by releasing a one-evening project to see how it went, (allegedly) used 'score enhancing' services to get some initial traffic to his game, and then once the heat got too intense decided to preserve his reputation by cutting loose and taking his earnings (probably at least $500,000).
Personally, I think that this whole story has exploded so much because it's an extreme example of where the 'clone development' culture of mobile games can lead, and people are expressing their disapproval of the process much like they did with Zynga a year ago. There's been a lot of concern and discussion for a few years now about what constitutes a true clone and where should the line be drawn. IMO, this is a clear example of overstepping the line.
But at the same time, that shouldn't be confused for saying that it's not OK to be heavily inspired by or pay tribute to games. Of course it's OK to build upon existing games, that's what the industry has been doing for 30+ years. This is where human discretion comes in, to define the difference between 'Doom vs Duke Nukem' and 'Tiny Tower vs Dream Heights'. One is an example of building upon an already great foundation to create something new and unique, whereas the other is a shameless move-for-move copy that simply switches a few things up and markets it better. I'm not a fan of the latter.