Quote from seirIt can get pretty unhealthy. As I already wrote, some guys are getting, lets say $7000, they are awesome so they earn a lot. Other guy with the same work time (work time is not experience!) can get even $2000 less because he's silent and with no giant success or just bad luck... You know what would happen if the second guy knows that he could get more $ just because showing his work a bit more (or stuff like this)? Madness. If industry would get a better classification for pay there would be no problem. Intern will get $A, Junior $B, Regular $C, Senior/Mentor $D, Team Lead $E and so on. The problem is that a lot of guys would be hurt by such classifications. Anyway, smart guys could get more classes like Senior Environment Artist, Team Leader and Mentor = $A+$B+$C.
I dunno, just thinking loud...
Yes, this definitely seems like a problem. Where I work there's clear banding of salaries, which is the only way it can really work fairly IMO. It's fine to pay people more if they're really good, but there should be bands that exist to cover such cases. This also aids career progression because if people are only getting incremental raises every year (i.e. barely covering inflation), sooner or later they'll hit a higher band and the company can take that opportunity to formally promote them and give them a few more responsibilities.
Without such a system, you can easily end up with the situation a lot of people in development (not just in gaming) end up in: working for years on end without being considered for any kind of new title, role, etc. This often isn't even a conscious decision on the company's part, they just have no systems to properly monitor people and help them succeed. Obviously some people are ambitious and won't settle for that, but many aren't yet are still invaluably productive — these guys usually end up disappearing one day after they've had enough of it, usually really jaded.