I'm kind of torn to be honest. On the one hand I don't think the world will be any worse off with a game that basically capitalises upon stalking and murdering (as opposed to other games which generally have some kind of motivation for doing so you can relate to), I find it difficult to criticise its deployment when we've got games like Postal out there, and films like Saw.
I'd imagine a major factor in the banning is of course the fact that the Wii version will almost certainly involve graphic reproductions of the murder with your own movements, which does take things to a slightly different level. Especially when, despite whatever anyone says, we all know full well that kids easily have access to these games, in large part of because of parent ignorance.
I don't think I'd be comfortable with my younger brother/sisters acting out the thrusts of a stabbing murder while a victim is mutilated in the name of fun, and indeed they wouldn't be allowed to play something of that level at home, but I know they'll get access to it at friends' houses because their parents don't really have the common sense to work out that an 18-rated game isn't suitable for a 9-year-old.
As far as the overall picture goes, I think this is probably a good move. Games that completely glorify mindless violence have never really worked for me, and I thought the Postal series was absolutely pathetic. Until game ratings are better monitored I don't think allowing something that is quite this graphic out there would be a good idea.
But then, I don't have a taste for these type of games so at the end of the day I don't really give a shit. ![]()
By the way, if a film was released commercially that is nothing more than two hours of extremely violent acted-out murders with no real justification, what would you think of the person who bought and watched it gleefully?