As I said I've not played INS yet so I have no idea how the theory carries over into actual gameplay, and it's simply a concern. I just have bad memories of the old Day of Defeat sniper rifle which had no crosshair when in normal view, but still had the accuracy and immense power of the sniper rifle. People would very frequently add something to the middle of their screen (using their other weapons' crosshairs as a reference) and then go around with an extremely effective rifle that can also zoom in.
Are you telling me that there's no potential for people to abuse this and get an unfair advantage in Insurgency? And I don't mean while running around -- I would assume the accuracy'd be reduced while moving anyway. Simply being able to stop dead and immediately start firing with a crosshair rather than moving into iron sights view sounds like it could make all the difference.
I'm also a fan of the no crosshair thing, but I'm aware that it can be exploited having been on the receiving end of people using a crosshair market in clan matches/etc in other games. This is why many games grounded in realism have tried it and then later abandoned it.