BF2142 was pretty popular for quite a while, it just died off and didn't seem to have the enduring popularity of BF2.
I think really they brought it out too soon, as a lot of what they tried to do (particularly the huge mothership thing) ended up being really rough, and also it played too similarly to BF2 for people to consider it a serious sequel. I guess it was a glorified mod, but it did refine a lot of BF2's gameplay to perfection IMO and took the unlock system from being a novelty to quite a serious mechanic and compelling reason to keep playing.
I think the sci-fi theme didn't help, either — people seem to really dig the modern combat thing. I suspect if BF2 and BF2142 swapped themes, the popularity would be the other way round. ![]()