It's such a brilliant concept in theory, but those old concerns raised from the outset are unfortunately still there: any kind of network latency and/or downtime is catastrophic, the video quality can be awful if your connection isn't speedy, and the game doesn't look as good as it would with your own hardware as they mandate turning off higher settings (including anti-aliasing).
I know for a fact that despite living in the absolute centre of a city, due to connection quality being so variable here I couldn't play games properly just like I can have issues with online video streaming if anyone else tries to use the connection.
There's also some fairly damning stuff summarised by Wikipedia:
QuoteDigitalFoundry conducted tests on OnLive that showed latency was greater than that for a locally-installed game. Best-case response times for button press to action was 10 frames or 150 ms, while other games ranged from 150 ms to 210 ms, and they noted that this would vary greatly depending on quality of connection to OnLive's servers. They also noted that such a response time "never meets anything like the claims made for it by company front-man Steve Perlman, on the record as describing end-to-end lag as being under 80 ms and 'usually... between 35-40 ms'.", and that while this may not be a problem for slower-paced games, for faster-paced games, "it is most definitely not a replacement for the local experience".Video quality was also analyzed with the finding that, owing to the use of video compression, "video quality is hugely variable in OnLive, ranging from very good to absolutely, diabolically dreadful. You will never get that disparity of performance on a local system", with video quality best when there was little motion or change in picture. Framerate and graphics quality was generally good, being comparable to the console versions of the games offered, but DigitalFoundry noted screen tearing due to the unlocked frame rate and the lack of full-screen anti-aliasing as mentioned by the developer briefing at GDC as being "mandatory".
In examining the value of the OnLive system, they noted that physical copies of games were often cheaper than those for use on OnLive, that OnLive's promise of better graphics quality than consoles counted for nothing if latency and video quality were inconsistent, and that the performance level could be "approximated or even exceeded" by purchasing an £80 graphics card bought for a computer that meets the minimum specification to use OnLive on a PC.
If connection speeds were extremely stable and extremely fast across the board it'd be fantastic, but until then it's just less hassle and cheaper to go with traditional console gaming and even PC gaming. ![]()