Christ. I was going to make a post saying you guys were overreacting, then I played the last ~90 minutes of the game.
QuoteIf I was to rate each of the 4 hours of the game from 1 (garbage) to 5 (amazing), it would go 3,4,3,2. At least some of the redeeming qualities were the greatly improved environment art over the first one. Unfortunately much of that gave way when you spent most of the game going through sewers and other nonsensical level designs. The story and voice acting wasn't as simple or well done as Amnesia, even at times the voice acting and writing felt very Dear Esther-y. I died three times, each time felt very cheap (two of which before I even knew I was in danger I was pinned in a dead end). The motion blur + slowed movement whenever lengthy dialog was happening became so god damn annoying. The puzzles mostly came down to you flipping or twisting a bunch of shit that didn't make any sense, then later you found out what you had to do, rather than the other way around. I got lost a bunch of times which kills any immersion or suspense that the game is trying so hard to build. WTF was that electrified pig?
I loved Amnesia but did not love this. 3/5 I am disappoint