Why has no one mentioned the Haunted house level in mario 64, I had nightmares about that.
Resident Evil on the gamecube is hella scary if you can stand the gameplay, I nearly shat my pants as I watched a zombie slowly.... well I wont spoil anything incase you havent played it 'yet'. But it was a slow thing, so it wasnt a cheap scare. I stopped playing because I needed to pick up an item but my inventory was full and you cant drop stuff.