Pilzsuppe Posted July 14, 2015 Report Posted July 14, 2015 (edited) Hey!We (TheLaiku and me) are fairly new mappers and excited to reveal our first competitive defusal map, DE_WORKSITE (Workshop link). Feedback is very important to us, because this is our first map and we hope to learn a lot from it. So please post any recommendations, annotations or criticism! Update 18.07.15 | Forum Post | Workshop Change LogUpdate 30.07.15 | Forum Post | Workshop Change LogUpdate 06.08.15 | Forum Post | Workshop Change LogUpdate 30.08.15 | Forum Post | Workshop Change Log The Terrorists have announced that they are fed up with the bad safety regulations of the city's worksites. The new buildings are known for being insecure and multiple workers have already died or were badly injured. They must bomb one of two targets to stop the construction and show the public what is going on. New ScreenshotsThe radar image. Here are some in-game screenshots of the map. If they don't show up for you, you can also find them in this Imgur album.The A bomsite. The Terrorists are entering from the right (not pictured) while the Counter-Terrorists can hold from the scaffolding or inside the site.A-long. The A bombsite is entered on the right and T-spawn can be seen in the distance.A-short. This area connects middle and the A bombsite on the right.CT-spawn is behind the truck. The A bombsite can quickly be entered from here.You can see T-spawn and the houses of the city behind it.Middle. A-short is entered on the left and you can get to B-long through the right wooden door.In front of the B bombsite. Here you can see where the CTs enter the site.The B bombsite. The Terrorists enter from the upper or smaller lower entrance. Counter-Terrorists get here from the broken hole or the big entrance next to it.The area right in front of the B bombsite.B-long is on the left and you can see T-spawn on the right side. Edit: We have changed the name from de_construction to de_worksite because we realized that there were already other maps with the same name in this contest.We hope you enjoy our map and are excited for your feedback!- Pilzsuppe Edited August 30, 2015 by Pilzsuppe Quote
soultron Posted July 14, 2015 Report Posted July 14, 2015 Can you update the radar to show hard walls and any entrances to sites? It's a bit hard to get a sense of exactly where entrances are from the topdown you have right now. Quote
Shima33 Posted July 15, 2015 Report Posted July 15, 2015 Name's a bit cliché, don't you think? Try and come up with a unique name - one where, if I search it on the workshop, only your map will come up. So far, it looks okay, but judging from the radar image, the actual playable level's too small for a competitive defusal map. The average for competitive defusal is anywhere between 3,000 and 4,500 - where's your map at, unit-wise? Quote
Jiro Posted July 15, 2015 Report Posted July 15, 2015 Yeah Shima33 is right, CT spawn and T spawn look way too close to each other. I'm sure u can smoke grenade the other spawn at start ... After this i dont know, your map is original because there is not really "paths" like long lanes, it can be cool if well handed but in my opinion you should use a classic layout.Graphically, it's cool. Quote
TheLaiku Posted July 15, 2015 Report Posted July 15, 2015 Thanks for the feedback everybody, it really helps us out! Can you update the radar to show hard walls and any entrances to sites? It's a bit hard to get a sense of exactly where entrances are from the topdown you have right now.This radar was just a quick version, we will update it soon to make it look more professional and easier to read.Name's a bit cliché, don't you think? Try and come up with a unique name - one where, if I search it on the workshop, only your map will come up.I don't know if you wrote this before or after the name change (there had already been another map called de_construction submitted to the contest, which we overlooked), but I agree that the name is nothing special. It's not final yet, so if you have any suggestions... So far, it looks okay, but judging from the radar image, the actual playable level's too small for a competitive defusal map. The average for competitive defusal is anywhere between 3,000 and 4,500 - where's your map at, unit-wise?We opted for a smaller level because of time limitations and since we are new mappers we wouldn't quite be able to pull of the attention to detail in a bigger level. The playable area is about 3000x2850, which is indeed small, but I believe this doesn't hinder competitive play too much.I'm sure u can smoke grenade the other spawn at start ... After this i dont know, your map is original because there is not really "paths" like long lanes, it can be cool if well handed but in my opinion you should use a classic layout.Overpowered grenade spots are a problem currently, but we have planned to edit the skybox in late development to make it more fair. Also, the map probably won't be undergoing major layout changes since we are pretty far into development. We will consider a more classic layout for our next projects though! Quote
Jiro Posted July 15, 2015 Report Posted July 15, 2015 (edited) Also, the map probably won't be undergoing major layout changes since we are pretty far into development.You are working on hammer, not on a game or something. You can easily copy and paste the "blocs" that are the core of your maps (Tspawn, CTspawn, A, B, The little rooms near bombsites, the middle) and add some corridors between them, i think the balance would be greatly improved, because right now looks like T can rotate way too fast between bombsites and CT can come from behind really fast aswell, making the gameplay way too nervous for counterstrike. + I think you should make the lighting brighter! Edited July 15, 2015 by Jiro forgive Quote
soultron Posted July 15, 2015 Report Posted July 15, 2015 (edited) I'll say this about the spawn proximities with respect to grenades: unless you have physical blockers above player height (think Overpass), players are going to hate if they throw grenades and have invisible collision knock them down or impede throw arcs in anyway. Come up with a strong tangible, physical justification (props, structural elements, etc.) or really take a long hard think about increasing the distance between spawns somehow.Also, I still think you should be in grayblock (instead of detailing, even with placeholder stuff) since there are issues with layout that could require major changes, but that's just my opinion. It probably doesn't matter much now since you're committed, saying that you're "pretty far into development."About the name: if you were to develop a stronger narrative reason the Ts want to bomb these sites (maybe one of the sites is a monument being erected that honours a corrupt politician or military general who committed warcrimes, for example) it'd be very easy to come up with a better name as a result. Honestly, I feel that bombing a construction site on the ground feels a bit weak, from a narrative and setting standpoint right now. de_vertigo did your exact concept, but because they staged their level on the top section of a skyscraper that was under construction, the name "vertigo" naturally came about. Just some stuff to consider. You don't have to do exotic stuff like make your construction site above ground, but you could alter small elements, like what is actually being built here and why someone would want to risk their life to bomb it to both provide inspiration for exotic props/depictions and a better name.Hope this helps. Edited July 15, 2015 by soultron ashton93 1 Quote
Pilzsuppe Posted July 18, 2015 Author Report Posted July 18, 2015 Hello again,we are happy to show you our first big update for the map since the announcement!ScreenshotsAnother view over B-long, this time from T-spawn.This is middle, as seen from A-long. Things will probably still change here a lot. Change Log 18.07.15 (Workshop Link):Added solid wall in middleAdded crate at B-longChanged door and wall in middleRemoved barrel on BExpanded street at B-long outside the mapAdded house at A long outside the mapAdded light and wooden plank for better viability at B longChanged ground texture in middleRemoved collision box from some curbsAdded many player clipsAdded new radarRewrote map story FeedbackWe appreciate your feedback during the week about the layout, but I hope you understand that we won't be able to undergo major changes to the layouts due to time limits. We would be very happy about smaller layout suggestions though!+ I think you should make the lighting brighter! The light from the sun is imo bright enough, but I have added a small worklight for better visibility at B-long, which is hidden in shadows. If you think of any other spots that are way to dark, please tell us!I'll say this about the spawn proximities with respect to grenades: unless you have physical blockers above player height (think Overpass), players are going to hate if they throw grenades and have invisible collision knock them down or impede throw arcs in anyway. Come up with a strong tangible, physical justification (props, structural elements, etc.) or really take a long hard think about increasing the distance between spawns somehow.We have added a few walls at middle / T-spawn to block nades, but we are not sure if want to put a ceiling above mid. There are already a lot of dark places in the map, but a solid glass ceiling is a possibility.About the name: if you were to develop a stronger narrative reason the Ts want to bomb these sites (maybe one of the sites is a monument being erected that honours a corrupt politician or military general who committed warcrimes, for example) it'd be very easy to come up with a better name as a result. Honestly, I feel that bombing a construction site on the ground feels a bit weak, from a narrative and setting standpoint right now. de_vertigo did your exact concept, but because they staged their level on the top section of a skyscraper that was under construction, the name "vertigo" naturally came about. Just some stuff to consider. You don't have to do exotic stuff like make your construction site above ground, but you could alter small elements, like what is actually being built here and why someone would want to risk their life to bomb it to both provide inspiration for exotic props/depictions and a better name.Hope this helps.The story has been changed to something to be a bit more serious: The reason for the Ts to bomb the construction site are the bad safety regulations and the death of multiple workers. We are planning to add blood decals and more detail to the places those accidents happened at. The update will hopefully have improved some things for you, and we are again looking forward to your reactions!- Pilzsuppe Quote
Pilzsuppe Posted July 30, 2015 Author Report Posted July 30, 2015 (edited) We are back with our second update!ScreenshotsThe new CT spawn. The brick house is gone and a playground, a truck and a dumpster was added. The small house and the crane was moved to here.Middle as seen from CT spawn. The electrical box was removed and the wood wall is thinner now.A long. The house has been refined and interior furniture was added.T spawn. Three houses were added here.Change Log 30.07.15 (Workshop Link)CT spawnAdded police truckRemoved brick houseMoved crane and added loadMoved small houseMiddleMade wood wall thinnerRemoved electrical boxA shortFixed self-boost spotsChanged gateB long + B bombsiteAdded blood decalsRetextured container on streetOutside mapAdded playground next to CT spawnAdded house behind middle / CT spawnAdded detail in house next to A longAdded additional house at A longAdded street behind T spawn and A longAdded three houses behind T spawnAdded detail in house at B long / T spawnAdded house behind water towersOverallAdded roof textures for spectatorsAdded many more playerclipsFixed many spots where bomb got stuckRemoved more collision boxes from curbsFixed bomb site names on radar- Pilzsuppe Edited August 6, 2015 by Pilzsuppe Quote
biXen Posted July 30, 2015 Report Posted July 30, 2015 Looks very good. Will add to my workshop and give it a run through. But honestly, it looks very dark. It makes me wonder if your monitor is set up properly. You should consider boosting it or playability will take a hit. Just look at the in-game maps. Quote
Pilzsuppe Posted August 3, 2015 Author Report Posted August 3, 2015 Looks very good. Will add to my workshop and give it a run through. But honestly, it looks very dark. It makes me wonder if your monitor is set up properly. You should consider boosting it or playability will take a hit. Just look at the in-game maps.Thanks for the feedback! I have set my in game brightness to full, but I don't think there is anything wrong with my monitor. You are already the second person suggesting this though, so we will definitely consider increasing the brightness in the next update. - Pilzsuppe Quote
Pilzsuppe Posted August 6, 2015 Author Report Posted August 6, 2015 (edited) We are happy to bring you our third update!ScreenshotsCT spawn on the left and middle on the right. The wall to short was detailed and CT spawn was changed a bit. You can already see the 3D skybox.A more clear look at the 3D skybox behind B long.The new house at A long.Change Log 06.08.15 (Workshop Link)CT spawnReplaced playground with houseAdded additional containerAdded detail to the wall towards A shortT spawnAdded vanAdded bricks on groundAdded interior in houseA siteAdded fire and dustcloud effect after explosionA longFixed toilet doorsRemoved railing from roofAdded detail to the second houseA shortRemoved doorFixed entrance from middle (you had to crouch from one side)MiddleAdded pipe to wallAdded cinder blocks and sheetrock on scaffolding outside BAdded extra box to prevent peeking on the stack of boxes near CTB longRemoved two wooden posts for better movement / visibilityMoved police barriersMade car glass more transparentAdded ropes to streetlightsB shortAdded pipe to wallAdded piece of broken wall and bricksB siteMoved wooden crateAdded fire and dustcloud effect after explosionOverallMore player clipsIncreased brightnessAdded ambient soundGeneral optimizationAdded 3D skyboxChanged fog to be less aggressiveAdded wind and tree swayImproved static reflectionsFeedbackBut honestly, it looks very dark. It makes me wonder if your monitor is set up properly. You should consider boosting it or playability will take a hit.We have now increased the brightness a bit, tell us if you like it! - Pilzsuppe Edited August 6, 2015 by Pilzsuppe Quote
Pilzsuppe Posted August 30, 2015 Author Report Posted August 30, 2015 We just uploaded the last update before the contest closes! This update is just the last bit of polish for the map, so there are no screenshots of any big changes. You can find a bunch of updated screenshots in the main post though!Change Log 30.08.15 (Workshop Link)CT spawnAdded telephone poles outside mapA longRemoved a few windowsChanged tower outside mapA shortChanged wall textureMiddleAdded additional barrels near B entranceB longChanged tree so it swaysAdded sparks to lightRetextured stairsRemoved hut behind water towersB siteAdded cableAdded explosion to floodlight after bomb explosionAdded dustmotes to lights OverallUpdated radar General optimizationAdded steam to chimneysAdded more player clipsRemoved collisions for most props outside the map - Pilzsuppe Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.