Jump to content

Carmack officially leaves iD


Recommended Posts

Posted

I guess id is now... doomed.

 

 

Honestly though I couldn't be more excited that he decided to join Occulus. I freaking love John Carmack and I've been super optimistic about what Oculus has been doing, so this just makes it all the better. Good for him, and I wish id the best.

Posted

Yup. Pretty happy about that! You can argue that it's the end of an era, but I think it was long overdue. He's a visionary and he's probably better off building the future of gaming :)

I for one am totally looking forward to what he'll bring to Virtual Reality!

Posted

Excellent news. I'm very glad he'll be innovating at Occulus once more. Because let's face it, Id was holding him back. Now is als the right time for Zenimax to do something about Id itself and start bringing us some proper titles based on Id's franchises.

Posted (edited)

In my eyes id "died" as soon as John Romero, Sandy Petersen and American McGee (who's probably my favorite level designer) left. Now I'm not saying id's games after Quake were bad (except maybe Quake 2), but they did not have the impact of their earlier titles even though they had great engines. I'm confident Carmack will do wonderful things at Oculus now. I think he should have done that years ago.

Edited by Skacky
Posted

Yeah, I've not really seen id as being particularly relevant for a long, long time. Sure they had huge impact with Wolfenstein, Doom, and Quake — and the pre-2000 engines of those games were a huge thing for the industry and still sit behind the technology of many of today's games. But apart from those successes, what has id really accomplished?

 

I can't think of anything they've done for about 13 years that's really had much of an effect on the community or industry. Doom 3 didn't do much for me even if it was a decent game, and Rage failed to draw me in beyond its technology too. The engines of those games haven't taken off either.

 

Carmack has definitely been wasted there. Game engines are too mature to be that interesting for him to work on, you can't have the same mindblowing steps forward that were accomplished in the early days. He's a pioneer and inventor, he should be building something like Oculus Rift which has the potential to transform gaming experiences if key technological issues can be overcome — something he specialises in. Not endlessly iterating graphical steps forward until the day he dies.

 

I hope he uses the rest of his life to bring as many of the incredible steps forward he did in his earlier days. I suspect he had some trouble letting go of id, but now he's done it he's a free man.

Posted

In my eyes id "died" as soon as John Romero, Sandy Petersen and American McGee (who's probably my favorite level designer) left. Now I'm not saying id's games after Quake were bad (except maybe Quake 2), but they did not have the impact of their earlier titles even though they had great engines. I'm confident Carmack will do wonderful things at Oculus now. I think he should have done that years ago.

 

I'm with you on that

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...