Jump to content

grapen

Members
  • Posts

    584
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    41

Posts posted by grapen

  1. @ThunderKeil you're in college? You're a young buck, you got all the time in the world to pursue LD, and YOU CAN DO IT. I was 29 when I decided I needed to make the switch. Did my 9 to 5 and worked on my portfolio in the evenings and at night. Took 2-3 years to land the job. Yeah it messed up my marriage, but I'm loving where I'm at in life right now. You just need to put the grind in, do your research on what it is that makes some portfolios stand out. Best of luck.

  2. Aight half-way or so in, here’s my honest opinion.

    Things I really like: excellent combat and excellent sound design. This is where the remake really flexes on the original. The original story beats are re-imagined in a great way. Monster design is great. The game looks good and runs great on an old ps4.

    Things I don’t like: the world building is OK.  I don’t buy the slums at all. All the NPC’s look upper middle class. The whole place looks gentrified rather than oppressed. Super weird. It’s like the NPC’s were ported from FF15. I think they should’ve gone hard on the 90’s punk aesthetic instead, and way less cheerful.

    The new content and story beats are inconsistent in quality. Sometimes they feel like typical anime (big emphasis here) filler episodes, which I would enjoy even less if this wasn’t FF7. Cloud even complains about it being boring, making the game appear self-aware. Weird design decision..

    Assets and texel density are WILDLY inconsistent in quality. Looks rushed in some areas.

    There’s still hope for the remaining new content to blow me away, but I don’t see my other points changing.

    I feel like an 8/10 is justified.

  3. I think it’s an OK game at best. 5/10.

    Level design is quite boring, especially the non-combat traversal. Exploration/secrets are predictable.  Enemies are tankier than what I’d like for them to be. Glory kills and chainsaw kills are tedius while at the same time absolutely necessary due to running out of ammo constantly.

    The perhaps biggest design flaw is introducing a boss and then taking you out of the action so the game can explain how to beat it..

    I don’t see myself continue playing, not having fun with it.

  4. The judges weren’t unanimous, but Mustang was not in enough top 4’s. That’s how it goes sometimes. ?

    Regarding the point about theme I disagree. Monastery is set in a Tibetan monastery, while Mustang is set in a traditional Nepalese village. More importantly, the execution is vastly different. Opinions may vary on gameplay and art polish, but on this point I won’t budge. ?

  5. 55 minutes ago, Wintrius said:

    This map actually put a smile on my face. I really love the visual style, and the layout might be the best one here. My only problems with the map are small nit-picks.

    -snip-

    This prop looks very out-of-place, and I'd suggest replacing it entirely. Putting a ramp here may also be interesting.

    -snip-

    Changing the bricks on this prop to gray and adjusting the color a bit would look a lot more fitting.

    -snip-

    A custom graffiti here would be very fitting.

    -snip-

    These rooms would look better with some new wall textures and details. Some custom paintings or furniture could also go a long way.

    Anyway, this is surely one of the greatest entries. You won't even need me to wish you luck, because you've already secured the top three with this map. 

    Thanks! They're on the to-do ?

  6. Digital copy vs physical copy. One or them deteriorates over time, costs more to produce and takes up space on store shelves. Second hand sales of one includes shipping costs (and assumes a good condition of the item), thus limiting the amount on the market. We didn’t have indies before digital distribution for a reason. It’s not very difficult to comprehend. With games you pay for an experience that costs a ton of money to produce these days, you can’t even compare it to how things used to be.

×
×
  • Create New...