Yeah, heh. I was definitely jaded. Again, written like 3 years ago, I was frustrated with a lot of indivuduals and saw, what looked like to me, a lot of people doing stuff just to create a big-shot name for themselves instead of for the love and passion of the art.
Was I right, wrong? Dunno, I never got that close to any of them, but I'm guessing you're mostly on the right track and that they were probably cool guys.
You mentioned competition too, and I just wanted to point out how valuable I feel friendly, constuctive one-upsmanship is to improving yourself. It happened between myself, andrew, and others on NS, and still happens at work now. I think that pushed the quality level of the maps that much further in both instances.